Lovely gift. Wrong size. Here’s how to return it
For a gift bought online from a professional seller, the person who bought it usually has 14 days from delivery to tell the seller they are withdrawing, subject to legal exceptions. For a gift bought in a physical shop with nothing wrong with it, an exchange depends on the shop’s policy. Start with the receipt or order confirmation. Find the seller, where the purchase was made and the purchase or delivery date.
Can you return a Christmas gift in Italy?
The jumper is lovely, the colour is just right and the size belongs to somebody else. Before taking off the label, look around. Is there a gift receipt in the box? Did the parcel arrive with an order number? Does the person who gave it to you remember where they bought it? It is an easier conversation if you know you would like the same jumper in the right size. Asking for the receipt can be a way of saying you want to wear it.
Online purchases: when do the 14 days start?
For a product bought at a distance from a professional seller, the ordinary deadline to notify them starts at delivery. If several products in one order arrive separately, count from the last one delivered. The date on the wrapping paper, the day you open it and the day somebody gives it to you may all be later. If the gift was bought in November, ask when the buyer received it. The seller may have extended returns over Christmas. Check the order terms to see whether the extension covers your product.
A purchase completed online and collected in a shop is still a distance purchase. If you only made a reservation online and concluded the purchase at the till, the position is different. On a marketplace, look at who is listed as the seller in the order confirmation. The right of withdrawal for consumers buying from a professional generally does not apply to sales between private individuals. The platform may still offer its own protection, with terms and deadlines attached to the order.
How to manage the return
Speak to the person who made the purchase. They may need to sign in to find the delivery date or start the return. If the seller has an online withdrawal option, follow the steps and save its confirmation. You can also notify the seller with an explicit statement that you are withdrawing. Include the order number and the product. Keep proof that you sent the message and keep the shipping receipt when you return the parcel. At a drop-off point, wait for the confirmation before leaving if the clerk scans a code from your phone.
Since 19 June 2026, the Italian Consumer Code provides for an easily accessible online withdrawal function for contracts made through an online interface where the right applies. Find the seller’s function and save the dated, time-stamped confirmation. Keep it with the original order email so you can match the return to the correct product if several gifts came in the same parcel.
Giving notice and sending the item back are separate steps. After notifying the seller, you normally have another 14 days to send back the goods unless the seller offers to collect them. The seller must reimburse you within 14 days of being told, but may wait for the goods or proof of posting unless they have offered collection. The money usually goes back to the original payment method. If the gift was paid for with the giver’s card, discuss it with them first. Check the return cost as well. The direct cost can fall to the customer if the seller told them before the purchase.
In a shop: find the conditions on the gift receipt
A physical shop can offer an exchange even when the item is fine. It may set a deadline, ask for the receipt and tags or offer a voucher. Look for the policy printed on the receipt, and call the shop if you cannot find it. To avoid a wasted trip, ask if a different branch accepts the exchange and if they can hold the size you need. If they need the original receipt, tell the person who bought the gift before you leave.
A gift receipt can show the information needed for an exchange without displaying the price. What it allows depends on the shop. If the item costs little and you would need to travel a long way, check whether the replacement is in stock before setting off. If you get a voucher, check its expiry date, which branches accept it and whether you can use it across several transactions.
If the gift is faulty
A lack of conformity is covered by the rules on the legal guarantee. For a new product, the guarantee lasts two years from delivery, and the seller is the person to contact. Repair or replacement comes first where the conditions are met. Take proof of purchase and explain the fault with an example. “It turns itself off after five minutes even when fully charged” gives the seller more to work with than “it doesn’t work”. If it happens intermittently, note when it occurs and which accessories you are using. A photograph can help if it shows the problem and contains no personal information.
Exceptions to the right to change your mind include clearly personalised goods, items that deteriorate quickly and certain sealed goods unsuitable for return for health or hygiene reasons once opened. Check the category before sending back a gift with a name engraved on it or a relevant seal you have broken. If the product is faulty, report the fault to the seller with the proof of purchase so they can handle it under the guarantee.
Before going out or booking collection
Set aside the packaging, accessories and instructions. Read the seller’s process and take a picture of your receipt so you have the number when asked. If you only want another size, confirm it is available before sending your gift away. If you want a refund, check who will receive it. You can then choose whether to visit the shop, write to the seller or ask the person who bought the gift to help you find any missing details.
SOURCES AND FURTHER READING
Share this story

